In a property settlement the valuation is usually obtained from a single expert instructed jointly by both parties, whose duty is to the court ahead of either side. Independence is the whole point. The report is written as expert evidence: the method is disclosed, the sales are analysed on the page, and the valuer must be ready to answer questions about it in a conference of experts or a courtroom.

The valuation is independent: one expert, instructed jointly, answerable to the court.

Valuations are ordered at the breakdown of a marriage or de facto relationship, for buy-outs of one party’s share, for consent orders and binding financial agreements, and for deceased estates, where a retrospective assessment at the date of death is usually part of the job.

Property valued in family law matters

  • The family home, usually the largest item in the property pool.
  • Investment properties, units and townhouses.
  • Business premises and commercial property.
  • Interests in land held through a company or a trust.
  • Acreage, lifestyle and rural residential property.

The single expert

The rules of the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia are built around the single expert witness. The parties jointly appoint one valuer, agree the instructions and share the cost. A party who wants to rely on a separately retained expert generally needs the court’s permission. The valuer has no relationship with either party worth speaking of, discloses any that exists, inspects with both parties aware of it, and answers to both sides equally.

A single expert’s report can be tested through written questions, a review by a shadow expert, or cross-examination. The report is prepared on that footing from the first inspection.

What the report contains

  • the instructions received and the date of value
  • the facts relied on and the inspection carried out
  • the comparable sales, each analysed and adjusted on the page
  • the reasoning that connects the evidence to the concluded market value
  • the valuer’s qualifications and registration

The relevant value is current market value, generally assessed close to the date of settlement or hearing. Markets move, and a figure from the date of separation can be well out of date by the time the matter resolves. The valuation belongs to the first step of a family law property settlement, identifying and valuing the asset pool, and an error there flows through every calculation that follows.

Deceased estate valuations

An executor administers the estate from a market value as at the date of death. The report fixes the interest being valued, the condition of the property as the deceased left it, any life interest, tenancy or encumbrance, and the purpose it is prepared for, so the beneficiaries, the accountant and if necessary the court can all work from the same figure. Where the need for a valuation surfaces years later, the assessment is a retrospective valuation at the date of death. Administration commonly runs for many months, and a deceased estate valuation at the date of death can be followed by a second assessment closer to distribution where the market has moved.

Inspection, fee and timing

Instructions usually come from the solicitors for both parties, or from the executor’s solicitor in an estate. Access is arranged through both parties or their solicitors. Send the property address, the stage the matter is at and any court directions about the appointment, and the practice replies with the scope, the timing and a fixed fee, usually the same day. Quotes are free. Reports are usually delivered 5 to 8 working days from inspection, and urgent timeframes are by arrangement.

To arrange a family law or estate valuation, request a valuation or call 07 3130 0723.

Common questions

Do both parties need their own valuer?

Usually not. The Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia works from a single expert jointly appointed by both parties, who share the cost. A party who wants to rely on a separate expert generally needs the court’s permission.

What date is the property valued at?

In a property settlement the relevant value is current market value, generally assessed close to the date of settlement or hearing. In a deceased estate the value is assessed as at the date of death.

Who instructs the valuer?

In family law the instructions are agreed in writing between the parties, usually through their solicitors, or settled by the court. In an estate the executor or the executor’s solicitor instructs.

Can the report be used in court?

Yes. It is written as expert evidence, with the instructions, the facts relied on, the sales evidence and the reasoning set out so it can be tested by written questions or cross-examination.

Rests on
Independent evidence prepared to single expert standards
Prepared for
Proceedings in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, executors, both legal teams
Have ready
Your solicitor’s details and any court directions about the appointment
Turnaround
5 to 8 working days from inspection; urgent timeframes by arrangement