Gross yield, net yield and the cap rate

Gross yield is the annual rent divided by the price. Net yield divides net operating income by the price, where net operating income is the rent less any vacancy allowance, less the outgoings the owner carries after recoveries from the tenant. No tenant reimburses outgoings on vacant space, so the vacancy allowance reduces recoveries as well as rent. A property bought for $2,000,000 and let at $140,000 a year has a gross yield of 7.00 per cent. If the tenant reimburses all $30,000 of outgoings, the net yield is also 7.00 per cent. If the owner carries them, net operating income falls to $110,000 and the net yield to 5.50 per cent.

Net income divided by price is the cap rate the price implies. Divide the same net income by a chosen cap rate and the result is a value: $110,000 at 6.50 per cent indicates about $1,692,000. A small change in the rate moves the value a long way, which is why a commercial valuation spends its effort proving the net income and the rate.

Outgoings and recoveries

Who pays the outgoings is set by the lease. Under a gross lease the owner pays them from the rent. Under a net lease the tenant reimburses most of them. Commercial leases often recover council rates, water, insurance and similar costs. Under a Queensland retail shop lease the landlord cannot recover land tax, excess payments under the landlord’s insurance policy or a body corporate sinking fund. Those costs stay with the owner. Enter rent and outgoings excluding GST.

Purchase costs and yield on cost

Commercial property is assessed for transfer duty at the Queensland general rates. On a dutiable value above $1,000,000 that is $38,025 plus $5.75 for each $100, or part of $100, over $1,000,000. On $2,000,000 the duty is $95,525. Adding duty and other purchase costs to the price gives yield on total cost: $140,000 on $2,095,525 is 6.68 per cent. Dutiable value is the price paid or the unencumbered value of the property, whichever is higher.

A leased commercial property can be sold GST-free as a going concern when the sale is for payment, the buyer is registered or required to be registered for GST, and both parties agree in writing that the sale is of a going concern. The property must be sold with its leases. Whether GST applies changes the cash a buyer needs at settlement, and your accountant confirms the treatment.

From a yield to a commercial valuation

Yield figures rest on the rent and outgoings entered. They do not test whether the passing rent is at market, how long the income lasts or how strong the tenant is. A signed commercial property valuation capitalises net market income at a rate drawn from analysed sales of comparable investments, and a market rent review tests the rent side. For houses and units, the rental yield calculator works from weekly rent.

Sources: Queensland Revenue Office, transfer duty rates and how to calculate transfer duty; Australian Taxation Office, selling a going concern; Retail Shop Leases Act 1994 (Qld) s 7(3).

Common questions

Is net yield the same as a cap rate?

The arithmetic is the same: net income divided by price. A cap rate in a valuation is drawn from analysed sales of comparable investments and applied to the property’s net market income. A net yield worked out on an asking price only shows what that price implies.

Should rent and outgoings include GST?

Enter both excluding GST, so the yield reflects the owner’s income.

Which outgoings can a landlord recover from a tenant?

It depends on the lease. Commercial leases often recover council rates, water, insurance and similar costs. Under a Queensland retail shop lease the landlord cannot recover land tax, excess payments under the landlord’s insurance policy or a body corporate sinking fund.

Is the sale of a leased commercial property GST-free?

It can be, as the supply of a going concern. The ATO conditions are that the sale is for payment, the buyer is registered or required to be registered for GST, and both parties agree in writing that the sale is of a going concern. The property must be sold with its leases. Your accountant confirms the treatment.

Does the duty figure include any concession?

No. Commercial property is assessed at the Queensland general transfer duty rates. The figure does not include foreign acquirer additional duty, which applies to residential land.