Most separating couples meet the court’s valuation rules for the first time when a solicitor asks them to agree on a valuer. The rules decide who chooses the valuer, what the valuer is told, who pays, the date the figure is struck at and how a party can test the result.
The date the property is valued at
Many people assume the family home is valued as at the date of separation. Section 79(3) of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) requires the court, in deciding what order, if any, to make, to identify the parties' existing legal and equitable rights and interests in property and their existing liabilities. Section 90SM applies the same test to de facto couples. Because the test looks to existing interests, the values that matter are generally current values, assessed as close to the hearing as is practical.
The court’s standard trial directions point the same way. The applicant serves a joint draft balance sheet at least 28 days before trial, the balance sheet is amended once any single expert valuation is completed, and the settled version is filed no later than 7 days before the trial date. A valuation from the month of separation can be well away from the market by then.

One valuer appointed for both parties
Part 7.1 of the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Family Law) Rules 2021 states its own purpose: expert evidence only on a significant issue in dispute, restricted to what is necessary, and given by a single expert witness where that is practicable, to avoid the cost of more than one expert. The pre-action procedures in Schedule 1 to the Rules ask the same of parties before proceedings start.
A single expert is appointed in one of two ways. The parties can agree to appoint one jointly (r 7.03), or the court can order that the evidence be given by a single expert (r 7.04), but only with that person’s consent. Where the parties cannot agree on who it should be, the court can order them to confer, or to hand up a list of experts who have consented, with the fee each will accept for a report and for attending court, and appoint from that list or in another way (r 7.05).
Once appointed, the valuer works for both sides equally. Except as the Rules permit, such as an agreed conference, neither party may communicate with the single expert alone, and any communication from one party goes to every other party at the same time (r 7.03). A party who wants a separately retained valuer to give evidence needs the court’s permission (r 7.10). The application is supported by an affidavit stating whether the party tried to agree on a single expert and why not, the expert’s name and field, the training, study or experience that qualifies them, the issue, why the evidence is necessary, and any previous connection between the expert and the party (r 7.11).
The letter of instruction
Instructions to any expert must be in writing (r 7.13). They must request a written report, say the report may be used in a proceeding, set out the issues the opinion is sought on, describe anything to be investigated, and make full and frank disclosure of the information and documents that will help the expert. The instructing party must also make sure the expert has the current version of Divisions 7.1.4 to 7.1.6 of the Rules and has read them.
For a single expert, the parties give the valuer an agreed statement of facts. If they cannot agree one, each party gives its own statement unless the court directs otherwise, and the court can settle the instructions itself (rr 7.05 and 7.13). For a property valuation, a letter that works covers:
- The property and the interest. Title details, whether the whole property or a share is being valued, and any lease or occupancy.
- The date or dates. Current market value, plus any past date the lawyers need, with the reason for it.
- The basis. Market value with vacant possession, or subject to an existing tenancy.
- The facts in dispute. Work done since separation, an unapproved structure, a defect, or anything else where the parties' accounts differ, so the valuer can report on each version if instructed to.
- The documents and access. Title search, plans and approvals, leases, records of recent work, and who arranges entry for the inspection.
Who pays and when
Unless the parties agree otherwise or the court orders otherwise, the parties are equally liable for a single expert’s reasonable fees and expenses of preparing the report (r 7.06). A party who puts questions to the expert pays for the answers, and conference fees are paid by the party who attends, or jointly where more than one party attends (r 7.28). A party who requires the expert at a hearing for cross-examination pays the reasonable fees of that attendance unless the court orders otherwise (r 7.09). For the report, a conference and any answers to questions, the expert does not have to start the work until the fees are paid or secured (rr 7.06 and 7.28).
Appraisals for negotiation, reports for trial
Not every figure in a family law matter has to come from a court-ready report. The instruction and disclosure rules in Division 7.1.4 do not apply to a market appraisal or opinion of value that a party obtains for a procedural hearing or conference (r 7.12). The court’s Central Practice Direction asks for a valuation or market appraisal of any real estate whose value is in dispute, provided no later than 14 days before a court-based dispute resolution event. Where the value is still contested at trial, the evidence is a full report that complies with rules 7.21 and 7.22: addressed to the court and the parties, verified by affidavit, and setting out the instructions, the facts and assumptions, the method and the reasons. Evidence of that kind rests on a full inspection, and every family law valuation the practice prepares is done on one.
Updating a valuation
Matters that run to a final hearing often outlast the first report. A move in the market to a later date is dealt with by a supplementary report on fresh instructions, given by agreement or as the court directs under its general power over a single expert (r 7.05). The valuer reviews the sales evidence to the new date and reports any change. Separately, if the valuer’s opinion in the original report changes, the valuer must give written notice to the instructing party, or to the Registry Manager and each party where the court appointed the valuer, and the notice forms part of the report (r 7.18). Because the property facts and instructions are already settled, an update from the same valuer usually involves less work than a fresh appointment.
Testing a single expert report
A party who disagrees with the figure has set steps and set time limits:
- Conference. Within 21 days after receiving the report, the parties may agree in writing to confer with the expert to clarify it. The expert must not be interrogated, and the court can order a conference where the parties cannot agree on one (r 7.25).
- Written questions. Questions go within 7 days after a conference, or within 21 days after receiving the report if there was none. They are in writing, put once only, limited to clarifying the report, and copied to every other party (r 7.26). The expert answers within 21 days after receiving them or after the fee for answering is paid or secured, whichever is later, and the answers become part of the report (r 7.27).
- A second expert. A party needs the court’s permission to rely on another valuer on the same issue. The court may give it if there is a substantial body of contrary opinion that is or may be necessary to decide the issue, if another expert knows of matters the single expert did not that may be necessary to decide it, or for another special reason (r 7.08).
- Cross-examination. A party who wants to cross-examine the single expert must tell the expert in writing at least 14 days before the hearing, and the court may limit the cross-examination (r 7.09).
Questions that work go to the comparable sales, the adjustments and the assumptions. Arguments about facts, such as whether an extension was approved, are better settled in the statement of facts before the inspection than raised after the report. Where the parties intend to rely on different valuers on the same question, the parties must arrange for the valuers to confer at least 28 days before the reports are first relied on, usually the first day of trial, and the valuers prepare a joint statement of what they agree on and where they differ (r 7.31).
Retrospective values and separation-date questions
Current value fixes the pool, but past dates can still matter. Contributions under section 79(4) are taken into account whether or not the property is still held by the parties, so a property sold after separation, mortgage payments or renovations by one party since separation, or a dispute about growth before and after separation can each call for a value at an earlier date. A retrospective valuation reconstructs the property as it stood at that date and values it from sales that settled around it. Whether a past-date value is needed, and which date, is a legal question for your solicitor, and both belong in the letter of instruction.
The inspection itself runs the same way as in any family law property valuation, arranged through both parties with both sides aware of the date. If you are separating, or briefing a single expert as a solicitor, call the practice on 07 3130 0723 to discuss a family law property valuation. Advice on how the rules apply to your matter comes from your family lawyer.
Common questions
Is property valued at the date of separation in a family law settlement?
Generally no. In deciding what order to make, the court identifies the parties' existing interests in property, so current values generally matter, assessed as close to the hearing as practical. A value at the separation date can still be relevant to contributions, and a retrospective valuation provides it.
Who pays for a single expert valuation?
Unless the parties agree otherwise or the court orders otherwise, the parties are equally liable for the single expert’s reasonable fees for preparing the report. A party who asks written questions pays for the answers, and a party who requires the expert for cross-examination pays for that attendance unless the court orders otherwise.
How long do we have to question a single expert’s report?
Written questions go within 21 days after receiving the report, or within 7 days after a conference with the expert if one is held. They are put once only and must be limited to clarifying the report. The expert answers within 21 days after receiving the questions or after the fee for answering is paid or secured, whichever is later.
Can each party get its own valuer?
A party can privately consult another valuer, but relying on that valuer’s evidence at a hearing needs the court’s permission. Where a single expert has reported, the court may give it if there is a substantial body of contrary opinion that is or may be necessary to decide the issue, if another expert knows of matters the single expert did not that may be necessary to decide it, or for another special reason.

